top of page
Search
Sean Joell Johnson, Esq.
Nov 6
3 min read
It’s Friday Night. Just Got Paid. Yeah, but what did you agree to? S.J.J. Law Group.

A deal can be legally sound and commercially wrong. The agreement can say exactly what everyone intended and still leave someone with a bargain they should not have made. Reviewing the language is essential. So is evaluating the rights, control and future flexibility being exchanged for the fee.


Consider a hypothetical filmmaker offered an attractive fee to create a short film for a brand. The proposed agreement also grants broad rights in future adaptations, approval over further development and exclusivity extending beyond the campaign. The fee pays for a production. The other provisions may shape the filmmaker’s next several opportunities.


What are you giving up?


Begin by separating the services commitment from the rights grant. Identify the deliverables, versions, revision rounds, approval process, delivery dates and payment milestones. Then identify precisely which rights the brand needs to exploit the funded project: media, territory, term, advertising uses, editing permissions and sublicensing.


Ownership, an exclusive license and a nonexclusive license are different arrangements. Under U.S. copyright law, copyright generally vests initially in the author, subject to exceptions including qualifying works made for hire. Paying for production does not, standing alone, resolve ownership. A copyright ownership transfer generally requires a writing signed by the owner or an authorized agent. The actual grant and the circumstances of creation need to be reviewed together.


A work-made-for-hire clause also deserves its own analysis. A label in an agreement does not by itself establish that the statutory requirements are satisfied. An employee’s work within the scope of employment and a qualifying specially commissioned work involve different tests. An assignment provision may have a separate effect even where work-made-for-hire treatment does not apply.


Future rights should receive a separate economic discussion. Does the brand need rights in the commissioned short, or also control over sequels, adaptations and a larger property? Identify preexisting materials and reserved rights. Where leverage permits, limit the grant to what the partner is actually funding. If broader rights are part of the bargain, negotiate their value, scope and conditions expressly.


Who can make things happen?


Ownership is only part of control. Approval rights, consultation rights and decision deadlines determine how a relationship functions. Specify which decisions require consent, who can give it, how submissions must be made and how quickly a response is due. Consider an escalation process or another expressly negotiated consequence for a missed deadline.


A retained right can have limited practical value if exercising it requires consent the other party has no contractual deadline to provide. Conversely, a brand may reasonably require protections around its trademarks, messaging and campaign use. The drafting should accommodate those interests without creating an indefinite veto over unrelated development.


Exclusivity should identify the restricted activities and category, the relevant competitors or projects, the territory and the duration. Address existing commitments, permitted outside work and a workable consent process. A narrow campaign restriction and a restriction on the filmmaker’s future services should not be priced as though they impose the same burden.


What happens when the plan stops moving?


A project can stall without either side behaving badly. Financing disappears. A campaign gets shelved. The agreement should address development milestones, payment for completed work, cancellation consequences, notice and cure periods where appropriate, and whether unused rights return after a defined event or outside date.


Ending services and ending a rights grant are separate drafting questions. State which obligations survive termination and whether an existing license continues. If contractual reversion is intended, specify its trigger, timing, conditions and the treatment of materials already distributed. Do not assume that cancellation automatically unwinds an assignment.


Contractual reversion should also be distinguished from statutory termination rights under copyright law. Those rights have separate eligibility, timing and notice requirements, and do not apply to works made for hire. They are not a substitute for negotiating a practical exit provision at the outset.


The headline fee tells you what comes in. The rights, control and exit provisions help tell you what the deal costs.


Sometimes a broad grant is commercially sensible. Sometimes certainty today is worth reduced flexibility tomorrow. The objective is a deliberate choice supported by clear drafting and compensation that reflects the whole bargain.


S.J.J. Law Group advises creators, talent, filmmakers, producers and businesses on entertainment agreements and the business decisions behind them. To discuss a proposed deal, contact contact@sjjlawgroup.com or call 323.435.6775.


This article provides general information about U.S. law and is not legal advice. The agreement, applicable law and circumstances of the engagement govern.


Sources: U.S. Copyright Office, Copyright Basics: https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ01.pdf ; Works Made for Hire: https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ30.pdf ; Copyright Act, Chapter 2 (ownership, transfers and termination): https://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap2.html


Comments


SJJ Law Group — Muted Blue Logo.png

S.J.J. Law Group PC

323.435.6775

 

Entertainment, intellectual property and business counsel for creators, brands, producers and founders.

Los Angeles, California

bottom of page